Press "Enter" to skip to content

Christmas Cookies Starting Information

Watch the introductory video HERE:

Help me find my missing Christmas cookies! I have compiled a list of suspects, along with addresses of the locations they claimed to be when my cookies went missing! Go to all locations listed below and look for a clue in the window. There you will find all the info you need to solve this mystery. When you think you have it narrowed down to one person send your suspect to by December 27th. Anyone with the correct suspect will be entered in a drawing to win a super fun goodie basket! Just one entry per family!

Thanks for your help and good luck! ~ Pastor Ben


  • Pamm
  • Mikayla Moore
  • Hilary
  • Trista
  • Emily
  • Naldia
  • Mikayla Bley
  • Jen


  • Aria’s Attic Boutique- 101 ½ W Market St, Nappanee
  • The Sugar Cream Cabin (The Barns at Nappanee) -1600 W Market St, Nappanee
  • Nappanee Missionary Church- 70417 ST. 19 N, Nappanee
  • Eastlake 24- 1530 E Market St, Nappanee
  • Rocket Science Ice Cream- 401 E Market St, Nappanee
  • Main Street Roasters (Not Coffee House) -105 N Main St, Nappanee
  • Jayla’s Flower and Gifts- 251 W Market St, Nappanee
  • The Dutch Kernel- 401 E Market St, Nappanee


The cookies are GONE! All that’s left are crumbs and frosting mess!
I know the cookies went missing before 12:00 noon.
Found this earring near the scene of the crime!